IoT exploration space
We design connected objects together, with cards instead of electronics. We work for one day with 8 to 20 people, and no technical background is needed.
Key facts
- 8-20 people
- 1 day
- no technical background required
- designing connected objects
Connected objects gather data from their surroundings and act on it. Whoever designs such things has a hand in deciding how people live in a city. This exploration space opens that decision up to people who are not specialists.
Non-specialists in the room
In the smart city debate, residents usually appear as trained users, rarely as designers. That is a convention, not a necessity. Someone who uses a street every day knows things about it that appear in no requirements list.
The barrier is real: without knowledge of electronics, network protocols or device configuration it is hard to have a say. That is why it takes a method that does not presuppose this knowledge, and that is exactly what the card method provides. It makes the building blocks of connected devices tangible without anyone having to read a data sheet.
Participation here does not mean being consulted about a finished design. It means working on the design before it is settled.
Schedule of the day
At the start, the group picks a scenario and a persona. The persona is the archetype of a user, with a name, needs and tasks; it can also stand for a group, such as older people or construction workers. The process does not begin without a persona. That is deliberate: the question of who something is for should not be an afterthought.
Next, the group picks everyday objects and extends them with sensors, services, interactions and responses. This might produce a bin with a tilt sensor that reports when it falls over, and with an air sensor that goes off in the heat. Further cards connect several devices into a single behaviour.
Finally, criteria cards put what the group has come up with back into question. The group looks at its own idea from an outside perspective and reworks it. Each concept is sketched on a storyboard and presented in two minutes.
The element of chance in the cards is part of the method. It keeps the space open and stops the group from reaching straight for the idea it already had.
Result
The day has two outcomes, and they are different.
The first is that the group makes the subject its own. Afterwards it understands how connected devices work, what they record and what questions that raises. This understanding is built together, not delivered in a talk. It holds whether or not anything is ever built.
The second is project development. Several worked-out ideas come out of the day. If applications are to follow, a second phase begins: the paper concept becomes a prototype with sensors and hardware, on which you can test whether the idea holds up.
Settle beforehand which of the two outcomes counts. Both are legitimate, but they lead to different agreements about what happens after the day.
Requirements
Nobody needs a technical background. I bring the cards and the board.
What the group should bring is local knowledge: whoever uses a street, a building or a working routine every day has more to contribute to this day than someone who knows the technology.
The group has eight to twenty people. With fewer than eight, the small groups become too thin. With more than twenty, the concepts can no longer all be presented and discussed in a single day.
Downloads
The cards and the board are published under CC BY-SA 4.0. You can download them, print them and work with them without me. The card backs are for double-sided printing.
German
English
Origin of the method
The Tiles IoT Toolkit was developed at NTNU Trondheim and is published under CC BY-SA 4.0. It consists of 153 cards in nine decks, plus a game board. Each deck contains one blank card so the group can add its own sensors, objects or personas.
I bring an adapted deck, in German when I work in German-speaking countries, and match the cards to each group. The standard cards work just as well.
Not suited for
The format does not fit where the expertise and a picture of the result are already in place. Once it is settled what is to be built, generating ideas is a detour.
Too much structure does as much harm as too little. Some groups find the constraints of the cards a hindrance, while others want more of them. That can be adjusted, but not predicted.
And the method works under time pressure. Anyone who copes badly with that contributes less in this format than they otherwise would.
Related
Request this exploration space
We agree the binding scope in a short preliminary talk.