The Excuses Compass

Twelve patterns of argument used to hold up political action.

When political action is debated, the arguments against it are remarkably stable. That holds whoever makes them, in whatever forum and about whatever specific proposal. The Excuses Compass documents twelve recurring patterns. Alone or in combination, they serve to delay regulatory action, to delegitimise it or to block it structurally.

Structure

Twelve cards are spread across four axes: shifting responsibility, resignation, playing down and harm through action. Each card shows a figure and its typical quote, and beside it the criticism, with sources for further reading.

There are four compasses, one for each field. The patterns recur from compass to compass, while the examples are different each time.

Limits

The compass does not settle any question of substance. An argument is not wrong just because it fits a pattern: some objections are justified, and the compass does not change that. It helps you recognise the pattern, so that the debate is about the matter itself rather than about putting it off.

The compass is published under CC BY-SA 4.0, and its source code is open. If you want to build a version for another field, you will find instructions in the repository.

About German debates

The compasses deal with German debates and cite German sources. They are translated in full, but the sources stay in their original language, because a search for a translated title would find nothing.

Overview

A compass for another field?

The source is open, and the instructions for rebuilding it come with it.

Let us talk about your project.

Call +49 228 629 380 60 I can be reached on working days. If I cannot pick up, I will call you back. Book appointment Take a free slot in the calendar A short conversation clears up a lot.